Archive for May 8th, 2008

h1

What’s the Fear?

May 8, 2008

I said in my last post that I had high hopes and great fears of what offering free high-caliber humanities scholarship to the public might do at large.

I think the hopes are obvious. I believe that humanities work is important in our development as a species. Maybe that’s a bit too grandiose but there’s nothing at all natural or necessary about democracy, for example. Its development and implementation took a lot of smart people thinking about the nature of governance and fighting to find that line between stable, functioning societies and individual liberty. We still haven’t gotten it totally right yet, and we probably never will–but that’s just one of the 100% priceless contributions the humanities have made toward making us freer, happier, better people.

Also, the humanities gave us Dr. Frankenstein and his monster, who, like Dr, Strangelove all those so many years later, reminds us to always look twice at what those scientists and mathematicians are doing when they get that gleam in their eyes.

Well, one fear is that when knowledge becomes free it stops being a tradeable commodity. And when that happens a lot of CPAs and MBAs running high on the inherent goodness they perceive in the economic marketplace will start to make cuts they deem as necessary and inadvertently hack off their nose to despite their face–CMU saves nine grand and we lose the minnesota review.

Perhaps more tragically in this tale is that if the “final issue” idea mentioned in the post comes to fruition, is there anyone at CMU that will care? Part of the problem is the people that bottom line reductionists think are important and the people that the culturati thinks are important are distinct, mostly exclusive sets. So when a parade of novelists, poets, or culture theorists talk about what a cynical act destroying the journal was and how it fits within the larger deterioration of culture studies, those responsible might just shrug and say “Who were they?”

I’m not advocating a ramping up of the monastic code of academics, nor am I advocating the imprisoning of knowledge up behind walls constructed of unaffordable online subscription fees. In the long run, free is going be better, no doubt. I fear the knee-jerk reactionism that creates suit-and-tie Queens of Hearts whose only solution to every internet-threat is “off with their heads!” That kind of “problem solving” merely creates a worst-of-both-worlds-scenario.

This entry was posted by: Jim
Advertisements
h1

This is What I’m Talking About

May 8, 2008

I have no idea what the long-term cultural repercussions of our rapidly open-sourcing of information will be, but I have my hopes.

High hopes and great fears.

The Stoa Consortium blog links to this article in the Chronicle of Higher Education which, in turn, links to this: the Open Humanities Press…which, like Luke Skywalker (or Harry Potter), has the potential to be a very powerful user of Good or Evil.

This entry was posted by: Jim
h1

Just Because You’re Paranoid…

May 8, 2008

So dig this humanities cats! The world works in mysterious ways, so to speak.

The Indiana Historical Society Press at some point published this book, which is about the history of the Irish in Indiana.
This book, called Boy, is the book from which the poem read on this morning’s edition of The Writer’s Almanac, was pulled.
And this album is the 1990 release from Irish rock band, U2, that also released an album called Boy.

Coincidence? You be the judge.

This entry was posted by: Jim
h1

Going Over All the Hurdles: A Life of Oatess Archey

May 8, 2008

The Indiana Historical Society Press announces the release of the newest book in its youth biography series:

Going over All the Hurdles: A Life of Oatess Archey, written by John A. Beineke, who lived in Marion and was one of Archey’s students, is the fifth volume in the IHS Press’s youth biography series. The book explores the career of Archey, the first African American to be elected sheriff in Indiana. Raised in Marion, Indiana, the young Archey and his loving family lived under the cloud of the notorious 1930 lynching. A star athlete, including winning the state championship in the high hurdles in 1955, Archey endured discrimination when he attempted to return to his hometown after college and tried to secure a teaching job with the Marion schools.

This entry was posted by: Jim